The Short Answer: Contrary to popular belief, Abner Doubleday did not invent baseball. The real story? Various forms of bat-and-ball games that existed before baseball led to the creation of the game.
We all know that baseball has long-since been America's favorite pastime. But have you ever stopped to think about how it all started?
Alexander Joy Cartwright and the Knickerbocker Base Ball Club of New York City get credit for being the first to craft their own rules, known as the Knickerbocker Rules, which were the first variation of the rules of baseball we know today.
The Myth of Who Invented Baseball
Most origin stories about baseball start with Abner Doubleday. He gets credited in old publications, his name sits on the ballfield in Cooperstown, and the claim has been repeated for over a century. But he did not invent the game.
Where the Story Came From
By the late 19th century, players and sportswriters were arguing over whether baseball was an American original or a version of the English game of rounders. Albert Spalding, a former pitcher who had built a sporting goods company, wanted the American answer. In 1905, he assembled the Mills Commission, chaired by former National League president Abraham Mills, to settle the question.
The commission worked for three years and released its report on December 30, 1907. It named Doubleday, a Civil War officer, as the inventor of baseball and placed the invention in Cooperstown, New York, in 1839.
That conclusion rested almost entirely on one letter. Abner Graves, a mining engineer who had grown up in Cooperstown, wrote to a newspaper saying he watched Doubleday invent a new version of the game as a boy. The commission took him at his word.
Debunking the Doubleday Myth
The story falls apart on three points.
-
Doubleday was not in Cooperstown. He was a cadet at West Point in 1839, and no record of leave places him anywhere near the town that year.
-
Graves was five years old. He was recalling early childhood events 66 years after they supposedly happened, and historians have questioned his reliability as a witness ever since.
-
Doubleday never claimed the game. He left behind extensive diaries and correspondence and died in 1893 without once mentioning baseball. None of his acquaintances connected him to it either.
The myth held up because it was a good story. A war hero drawing the first diamond in a small New York town gave a popular American sport a clean and patriotic beginning. Historians took it apart decades ago, though Cooperstown still has the Baseball Hall of Fame and Doubleday Field still stands
Where Did Baseball Truly Originate?
One theory suggests that baseball evolved from English games, specifically from a game known as rounders. This was a bat-and-ball game involving running around bases without being tagged out, which is often quoted as a predecessor of baseball.
Another English game that may have influenced the invention of baseball is "stoolball." In this game, a batter defended a stool from being hit by a round ball thrown by a pitcher. Elements of "stool ball" can still be seen in the game of baseball today, such as the core concept of a pitcher throwing a ball towards a target while a batter tries to hit the ball.
The Evolution of Baseball
Baseball in America
The first known reference to a game labeled "base-ball" in the United States appeared in the early 18th century. It quickly became a favorite pastime of miners and migrant workers who spread the game as they moved from town to town. In the early days, “base-ball” was a loosely structured game played by everyday people for entertainment.
The Birth of Modern Baseball
The original bat-and-ball game, which emerged in the 18th century was drastically different from the structured, rule-based game we know today. Alexander Cartwright, a prominent figure of the New York Knickerbockers, laid down a set of rules for a bat-and-ball game in 1845 that was the first adaptation of the rules of baseball. These rules, referred to as the Knickerbocker Rules, created the iconic rules of a fixed diamond-shaped infield, foul lines, and a three-strike rule.
The Emergence of Major League Baseball
One of the key turning points in the history of baseball was the formation of Major League Baseball. The formation of the National League in 1876 and the American League in 1901 helped to standardize the game, implement professional practices, and brought a level of commercial viability by attracting spectators to their games. Historical baseball teams such as the New York Yankees, the Houston Astros, the Los Angeles Dodgers, and the Detroit Tigers emerged from these leagues.
The Game Today
Today, with professional baseball leagues in and beyond the United States, baseball truly is an international affair. From a cluster of college campuses along the East Coast to the heart of Japan, the spirit of baseball lives in every crack of the bat, every roar of the crowd, and every child watching a home run, dreaming of one day becoming a big-league player.
Carrying the Game Forward
While deep-diving into baseball's origins, we can't help but marvel at the evolution and growth of the game. This spirit of evolution and excellence is at the core of BRUCE BOLT. Every product, every design, every stitch pays homage to the pioneers who influenced the creation of the game we love.
Players today swing harder, see faster pitching, and play longer seasons than any generation before them. The gear has to keep up. Our batting gloves are hand-sewn from 0.9mm Cabretta leather for grip that holds through a full season, and our protective gear covers the rest of your at-bat with elbow guards, leg guards, hand guards, and sliding mitts.
Shop our full collection of baseball accessories and get set for your next game with BRUCE BOLT.
